How to Compare Merchant Account Quotes on the Same Month of Volume
The way to compare merchant account quotes is to give every provider the same recent statement, ask each one for a complete written quote, and then price all of them against that one month of volume. The quote with the lowest total dollars on your own numbers wins, not the one with the lowest rate printed at the top. If you’re figuring out how to compare merchant account quotes for the first time, that one rule will save you most of the trouble.
We sit across from owners holding three or four proposals that can’t be lined up against each other, because each salesperson quoted a different thing. Below is how to make them comparable, what a full quote has to include, a side-by-side example with three made-up quotes, and the warning signs we look for.
Why most merchant account quotes can’t be compared
A merchant services quote usually shows up as a single page with a big percentage on it. One provider writes 1.59%, another writes 2.75%, and a third writes “interchange plus 0.40%.” Those numbers describe three different pricing models, so putting them side by side tells you almost nothing about what you’ll pay.
The percentage also leaves things out. Per transaction fees, monthly fees, PCI compliance fees, gateway charges, equipment payments and contract terms all sit somewhere else in the paperwork, if they’re written down at all. Two quotes with the same headline rate can be hundreds of dollars a month apart once those are added in.
And each salesperson builds the quote from whatever you told them. If you said “about forty grand a month” to one and handed a statement to another, you’ve got two quotes built on different assumptions about card mix, average ticket and payment types.
How to get quotes you can line up side by side
Send everyone the same statement
Pick one recent processing statement, ideally a normal month that isn’t your slowest or your busiest, and send that exact statement to every provider. Two or three recent processing statements are better if you have them, since they smooth out a strange month. Your processing history tells a provider your volume, your number of transactions, your average ticket, and how much of it is debit cards, rewards credit, corporate card, keyed or online sales.
That last part matters more than most owners expect. Card mix drives interchange fees, and interchange is the biggest piece of anyone’s processing costs. A quote built from your statement prices your customers’ cards. A quote built from a phone call prices somebody’s guess.
If you’re a new business with no processing history yet, give every provider the same written estimate: monthly volume, average ticket, the share you expect in person versus online, and your business type. Same inputs, same comparison.
Ask for the quote in writing, on your numbers
Ask each payment processor or agent to show you what last month would have cost on their pricing, in dollars, using the statement you sent. A provider who prices your real month can’t hide behind a rate, and one who won’t do it is telling you something.
Have the basic business documents ready too: a voided check, your EIN, and owner ID. You don’t need them to get a quote, but having them on hand means you can move once you’ve picked the right provider.
What a complete merchant account quote must show
A real quote covers everything that will show up on your monthly statement and everything in the merchant services agreement that could cost you money later. If any of these items is missing, ask for it in writing before you compare.
The pricing model and the markup
The quote should name its pricing structure. The common pricing models are interchange plus, tiered, flat rate and subscription, plus cash discount or dual pricing programs. Each one handles interchange differently, so the model tells you how to read every other number.
With interchange plus pricing, the quote should state the markup as a percentage and a per-item fee on top of wholesale interchange rates and network assessments. With tiered pricing, it should list every tier’s rate and explain which transactions land in which tier. Flat rate pricing should show the rate for each payment type, because in-person, keyed and online sales are often priced differently.
Per-item and transaction fees
Look for the flat fee charged on each transaction, plus any separate authorization fee, batch fee, AVS fee or gateway per-transaction fee. On a small average ticket, these cents can cost more than the percentage. If a quote lists a 10 cent fee in one place and a 10 cent authorization fee somewhere else, you’re paying 20 cents.
Every monthly, annual, PCI, gateway and software fee
Make the provider list each recurring charge by name and amount. The usual suspects:
- Monthly fee, account fee, statement fees or “service” fees
- Monthly minimum fee (you pay the difference if your markup falls short of it)
- PCI compliance fees and any non-compliance fee
- Gateway fees for online sales, an online store or recurring billing
- Software or point of sale subscription fees
- Annual fees, and what each one covers
- Chargeback, retrieval and ACH reject fees
Some of these are legitimate. A gateway for your ecommerce site costs money to run, point of sale software is a real product, and an annual fee can cover real expenses. A fee nobody can explain to you is padding.
Hardware terms
The quote should say whether payment terminals are free, purchased or leased, and if leased, for how much, for how long, and who the leasing company is. A low monthly lease through your processor that ends when you cancel is one thing. A 48-month, non-cancelable lease with a third-party leasing company is another, and it stays with you even after you switch processors. We’ve written more about that in the terminal lease trap.
Contract length and early termination fees
Ask for the contract length, whether it auto-renews, how much notice you have to give to cancel, and the exact early termination fees. Some agreements have a flat ETF. Others use “liquidated damages,” which can be your average monthly fees times the months left on the term. Long term contracts with automatic renewal are still common in this industry, and the cancellation window is often a 30 to 60 day slot you’ll miss if you don’t put it on a calendar.
Funding time
Ask when deposits land. Next business day is common, some providers take two or more business days, and some offer same day funding once you’ve processed with them for a while. Funding speed affects cash flow, especially for small businesses that pay suppliers out of daily deposits.
A worked side-by-side comparison
Here are three quotes priced on the same month. Every number is illustrative and made up for this example, not any provider’s real pricing. The point is the method.
The sample month is $40,000 in card volume across 500 transactions, for an $80 average ticket. We’ll assume the interchange and card network assessments for this card mix come to $800, or 2.00% of volume. That figure is the actual cost every provider pays before adding its own markup, and it doesn’t change based on who sold you the account.
The three quotes
Quote A is tiered: 1.59% qualified, 2.49% mid-qualified, 3.29% non-qualified, a 20 cent per-item fee, a $9.95 statement fee, a $15 gateway fee, $99 a year for PCI, a $25 monthly minimum, a three-year contract with a $495 early termination fee, and a terminal on a 48-month lease at $69 a month. For this month, the provider’s own sorting puts 40% of volume in qualified, 35% in mid-qualified and 25% in non-qualified.
Quote B is flat rate: 2.75% plus 10 cents on every in-person sale, no monthly fees, no contract, and a card reader you buy outright.
Quote C is interchange plus: pass-through interchange and assessments, plus 0.40% and 10 cents per item, a $15 monthly account fee, $79 a year for PCI, month to month.
| Line item (one month) | Quote A: tiered | Quote B: flat rate | Quote C: interchange plus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headline rate on the proposal | 1.59% | 2.75% | IC + 0.40% |
| Percentage charges | $932.00 | $1,100.00 | $960.00 ($800 interchange + $160 markup) |
| Per-item fees (500 sales) | $100.00 | $50.00 | $50.00 |
| Statement / account fee | $9.95 | $0.00 | $15.00 |
| Gateway fee | $15.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| PCI fee (annual spread monthly) | $8.25 | $0.00 | $6.58 |
| Terminal lease | $69.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 |
| Total for the month | $1,134.20 | $1,150.00 | $1,031.58 |
| Effective rate | 2.84% | 2.88% | 2.58% |
| Contract and ETF | 3 years, $495 ETF | None | Month to month |
| Hardware | 48-month lease, about $3,312 over the term | Reader purchased up front | Not included in quote |
| Funding (as quoted) | 2 business days | Next business day | Next business day |
What the table tells you
Quote A had the lowest rate on the page and ended up in second place, and only because this example was generous about how the provider sorted the tiers. On a month with more rewards cards or keyed sales, more of the volume drops into the 3.29% bucket and A gets worse. It also carries a lease that outlives the contract, and a fee for leaving.
Quote B is easy to understand, and at low volume it’s a reasonable choice. On $40,000 a month you’re paying about $118 more than Quote C for that simplicity, which comes to over $1,400 a year.
Quote C costs the least here, and because interchange is passed through at cost, you can check it against your statement every month. Note that C didn’t include hardware, so ask what a terminal would cost before you call it the winner.
The one number that settles it is the effective rate: total fees divided by total card volume. Our effective rate calculator will work it out for your current statement and for any quote you price on the same month. For a reference point, most small businesses pay somewhere around 2.5% to 3.5% all in, according to Clearly Payments, though we’ve seen statements as high as 8%.
Red flags in a credit card processing quote
A rate with nothing around it
A quote that’s one percentage and a signature line isn’t a quote. If the provider can’t show you the per-item fees, the monthly fees and the contract terms on the same page, assume they’re there and you’ll meet them later. Ask for the full fee schedule before you sign anything.
The “qualified rate” pitch
A salesperson who leads with a qualified rate is selling you the cheapest tier. Most cards your customers carry, including rewards credit, corporate cards and keyed transactions, often won’t land there. The processor decides what qualifies, and it can change the rules. Ask what share of your last month would have landed in each tier, and get it on your statement’s numbers.
Leases buried in the paperwork
Equipment leases often come as a separate agreement with a different company, handed over in the same stack as the merchant application. Read every page you sign. Look for “non-cancelable,” a lease term in months, and a leasing company name that isn’t your processor.
Teaser rates
Some quotes start low and climb. Watch for language that lets the provider change pricing with notice on a statement message, rates that are “promotional,” or markup increases labeled as interchange changes. If your rate creeps up a few months in, that’s often why. Ask the provider to put in writing how and when your pricing can change.
Hidden fees that only show up later
Hidden fees usually aren’t hidden in the agreement. They’re in the fine print of the fee schedule, or on a page the salesperson skipped. Non-compliance PCI fees, monthly minimums, “regulatory” fees and annual fees with no explanation are the common ones. If you want help picking a statement apart, our guide to reading a merchant statement shows where each of these lines tends to sit.
Questions to ask every merchant services provider
Ask these of each provider and get the answers in writing. If you’re comparing credit card processing rates across three providers, the same list keeps the answers comparable.
- What would my last month have cost on your pricing, in total dollars?
- Which pricing model is this, and what is your markup over interchange?
- What is every fee that could appear on my statement, monthly or annual, and what does each one cover?
- Is there a contract, how long is it, does it auto-renew, and what are the early termination fees?
- Is the equipment purchased, free, or leased? If leased, with whom, for how long, and can I cancel it?
- How can my pricing change after I sign, and how will you tell me?
- When will deposits hit my account, and can that move to same day funding later?
- Who do I call when something breaks? Is there a dedicated account manager or a general technical support line, and what hours?
- Does the system handle the payment types I take: in person, keyed, online sales, recurring billing?
Reliable customer support doesn’t show up on a rate sheet, but it shows up on the Friday night your terminal stops taking cards. Ask how support works before you need it.
How our own quotes compare
We’re an independent sales organization, so we’d be a strange shop to write this and not hold ourselves to it. DFW Pay Pros charges no monthly fees. The only other charges you might see are software fees, if your setup needs the software, and in some cases an annual fee to cover expenses. If you see one on our quote, ask what it covers and we’ll tell you.
There’s no contract. Accounts are month to month, you can cancel any time at no cost, and there’s no early termination fee. The first terminal is free for most businesses, and additional or upgraded hardware is free or a low monthly lease, quoted before you sign. Funding is usually next business day, and after you’ve processed for a while, accounts can move to same-day funding.
We also offer a 4% cash discount, or dual pricing, program where you post a cash price and a card price. It changes who covers the card cost, so it’s worth pricing as a separate option against your current setup rather than mixing it into a rate comparison.
Frequently asked questions
How much do merchant services cost?
It depends on your card mix, average ticket and pricing model, but most small businesses pay roughly 2.5% to 3.5% of card volume all in once every fee is counted. The only way to know your number is to divide your total fees by your total card volume on a recent statement.
Who has the cheapest credit card processing rates?
There isn’t a single answer, because the cheapest provider for a coffee shop with $6 tickets may be expensive for a law firm with $2,000 invoices. Interchange is the same everywhere, so price each quote on your own statement and compare total dollars.
Can you legally charge a credit card processing fee?
Often, yes, but the rules depend on how you do it. A credit card surcharge is capped by the card networks (Visa at 3%, Mastercard at 4%, never above your cost of acceptance), requires 30 days’ notice to your acquiring bank, and is banned outright in some states, so check current state law. Dual pricing, where every item shows a cash price and a card price, is legal in all 50 states as long as both prices are displayed.
Is it illegal to charge a 3% fee on a debit card?
Card network rules don’t allow surcharging debit cards or prepaid cards, even when the customer runs it as credit. A cash discount or dual pricing program works differently, because you’re setting your own prices rather than adding a fee to a card sale.
What is a merchant account statement?
It’s the monthly report from your processor showing your card volume, number of transactions, and every fee you were charged. It’s also the single most useful document you can hand a provider when you ask for a quote.
Get a quote you can check
If you’ve got a stack of proposals and can’t tell which one is cheapest, send us your most recent statement along with them. As an independent sales organization, we’ll price your actual month on our offer, line it up next to the others the same way as the table above, and show you the effective rate on each. There’s no contract, it’s month to month, and there’s no early termination fee if you decide to leave. Start with a free statement review, and with statements up front, approval can come in as little as 24 hours.