PCI Compliance Fee vs. Non-Compliance Fee: What You’re Paying and How to Stop It
A PCI compliance fee is a charge your processor bills every account to run its PCI program, usually once a year or a few dollars a month. A PCI non-compliance fee is a separate monthly penalty the processor adds when it has no current proof that you’re PCI compliant. You can’t always get rid of the first one, but you can almost always stop the second one by finishing your self-assessment questionnaire and, if your setup requires it, passing your quarterly scans.
Owners mix the two up all the time, and processors don’t go out of their way to explain them. Both have “PCI” in the name, both show up in the fees section of the statement, and both are set by your processor rather than by Visa or Mastercard. Telling them apart matters because the penalty keeps billing every month until you stop it. Below we cover where each fee shows up, who’s behind it, what it tends to run, and how to get rid of the penalty.
What PCI DSS compliance is, in one paragraph
PCI DSS, the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard, is the rulebook for any business that stores, processes or transmits credit card information. The PCI Security Standards Council writes and maintains it, and the PCI DSS requirements cover things like network security, access controls, encryption and how you handle security incidents. The major credit card companies that founded the council (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover and JCB) require it through their own programs, and your acquiring bank enforces it on your account through your merchant agreement. The point of all of it is to protect cardholder data and keep data breaches from happening in the first place. Merchants are sorted into four PCI compliance levels by annual transaction volume, and nearly every small business lands in the lowest one, which is the level that validates with a self-assessment questionnaire instead of an outside auditor.
If you want the longer explanation of merchant levels, SAQ types and the security controls themselves, our guide to PCI compliance for small businesses covers it. This page sticks to the fees.
PCI compliance fee vs. PCI non-compliance fee
These are two different charges with two different triggers. One is a cost of having a merchant account with that processor. The other is a penalty for not filing your paperwork.
| PCI compliance fee | PCI non-compliance fee | |
|---|---|---|
| Common names on a statement | PCI annual fee, PCI program fee, compliance fee, security program fee, data protection fee | PCI non-compliance, non-validation fee, PCI non-receipt fee, compliance penalty |
| Who gets charged | Usually every merchant on the account’s pricing | Only merchants without current validation on file |
| How often | Once a year, or a small monthly amount | Every month until you validate |
| What it pays for | The processor’s compliance portal, scanning tools, support, and in some cases breach coverage | Nothing you receive; it’s there to push you to validate and to cover the processor’s risk |
| Can you stop it? | Sometimes, by negotiating or choosing a processor that doesn’t charge it | Yes, by completing your SAQ and any required scans |
The compliance or program fee
The PCI compliance fee is what the processor charges to run its compliance program. Most processors contract with a third-party compliance company that gives you an online portal, walks you through the self assessment questionnaire, and runs scans if your setup needs them. Some processors bundle a small amount of breach coverage into the same fee, which can help with forensic investigation costs or card replacement costs if a data breach occurs. Ask whether yours does, because many owners are paying for coverage they don’t know they have.
It’s a real service with a real cost behind it, and also a profit line for a lot of processors, which is why the amount varies so much for what amounts to the same portal.
The non-compliance fee
The PCI non-compliance fee is a penalty, and it’s the one that hurts. Your processor charges it when your compliance status shows as not validated, which usually means you never completed the SAQ, you completed it more than a year ago, or a required quarterly scan failed or was never run.
Processors say the fee covers the extra risk of carrying a merchant who hasn’t shown proof of compliance. That’s partly true. If a non-compliant business has a breach, the card brands can assess the acquiring bank, and the bank passes those financial penalties down. But the monthly non compliance fee is still the processor’s charge, set at the processor’s price, and it keeps coming whether or not anything bad ever happens.
Who charges PCI fees (and who doesn’t)
The PCI Security Standards Council doesn’t bill merchants. Visa and Mastercard don’t put a PCI line on your statement either. Every PCI fee you see on your payment processing statement comes from your processor or the bank behind it.
The council writes the PCI standards. The card brands decide how those standards are enforced and can fine acquirers. Acquiring banks and payment processors then decide what to charge you to run a program, and what to charge you for skipping it.
So when a sales rep tells you “that’s a Visa fee” or “the PCI Council requires it,” be skeptical. PCI compliance is mandatory under your merchant agreement, but the price tag on the program is a business decision your processor made. It’s not federal law either; PCI DSS is an industry standard enforced through contracts, though some states have their own data security and breach notification laws.
Where PCI fees show up on your merchant account statement
Look in the section labeled something like “Fees,” “Account Fees,” “Other Fees” or “Miscellaneous.” PCI charges rarely appear on the summary page next to your discount rate. They sit with the statement fee, batch fees and other recurring fees.
A few patterns to watch for:
- A charge that appears once a year, often in the same month you opened the account, is usually the annual PCI fee.
- A smaller charge every month with “PCI” or “compliance” in the name is usually a monthly program fee.
- A larger monthly charge that started a year or so after you signed, or after a processor change, is often the non-compliance fee.
- Two PCI lines in the same month generally means you’re paying the program fee and the penalty at once.
Names vary a lot by processor. If a line is vague, our statement fees glossary lists the common labels, and how to read a merchant statement shows where each section usually sits.
Why payment processors charge PCI fees
The processor pays a compliance vendor for the portal and scanning service, and it passes that cost to you. The acquiring bank carries liability if one of its merchants has a breach, and the card brands can hold the bank responsible. And the processor has to report to the card brands on how many of its small merchants are validating, so it has a reason to push you toward finishing the paperwork.
The other reason is margin. A PCI fee costs the processor very little per account once the vendor contract is in place, and it’s billed to thousands of merchants who never look at it. The non-compliance fee in particular earns more when merchants ignore it, which is why some processors don’t make it easy to find the portal login.
Typical PCI compliance costs, as illustration
We won’t quote any processor’s current price, because they change and they differ by contract. The cost of PCI validation for a small merchant is mostly these flat charges, separate from your transaction fees. The figures below are illustrative, meant to show the shape of what small businesses tend to see, not anyone’s actual rate.
| Charge | Illustrative amount | Illustrative yearly total |
|---|---|---|
| Annual PCI program fee | $99 once a year | $99 |
| Monthly PCI program fee | $8.95 a month | $107.40 |
| PCI non-compliance fee | $29.95 a month | $359.40 |
| Program fee plus non-compliance fee | $8.95 + $29.95 a month | $466.80 |
We see that last row on statements more often than we’d like. A small shop doing modest transaction volume can end up paying several hundred dollars a year in PCI charges, most of it a penalty that a half hour of paperwork would have stopped. We look for unnecessary fees like that first.
These fees are flat, so the smaller your annual transaction volume, the bigger the bite as a share of what you process.
How to avoid a PCI non-compliance fee
For most small businesses, stopping it takes a few steps, in this order.
- Find your portal. Call your processor and ask for the PCI compliance portal link and your login.
- Confirm your SAQ type. The portal usually asks how you take cards (a standalone terminal, a POS system, an online store, a virtual terminal) and picks the questionnaire for you. Answer carefully, because the wrong type means the wrong questions.
- Complete the self assessment questionnaire (SAQ). For a business using a modern terminal with no stored card data, this is often a short form. It asks about things like access controls, how you handle paper receipts, and whether you store sensitive cardholder data anywhere.
- Run quarterly scans if your setup requires them. Some SAQ types, typically for businesses with card data passing over an internet-connected network or an e-commerce site, require quarterly vulnerability scans by an approved scanning vendor. These quarterly network scans check the outside of your payment environment for known weaknesses. The portal will tell you whether yours does.
- Sign the attestation and get confirmation. Once you submit, ask the processor to confirm your compliance status changed to validated and when the fee will stop. Keep a copy of the completed SAQ and the attestation. Maintain documentation like this in one folder so you can prove compliance with PCI DSS if anyone asks.
- Check next month’s statement. If the non-compliance fee still shows up after the processor confirmed your status, call and ask for it to be removed and credited. Going forward, open any compliance notice from your processor when it arrives, since responding quickly keeps the fee from starting.
Ongoing compliance is a yearly job
Maintaining PCI compliance is a yearly routine. The SAQ has to be renewed every year, and scans, where required, every quarter. The usual way the fee comes back is a merchant who filed once, forgot the anniversary, and got charged again thirteen months later. Put the renewal date on the calendar the day you submit to ensure ongoing compliance.
Maintaining compliance also means telling your processor when your setup changes. If you add an online store, switch to a different POS, or start taking phone orders on a virtual terminal, your SAQ type can change, and a questionnaire filed under the old setup may no longer count. The reverse also works in your favor. Moving to payment systems that keep card data off your own network, such as a hosted payment page or a validated point-to-point encryption device, can shrink the questionnaire and sometimes drop the scan requirement.
Ask for a credit on fees already paid
If you’ve been paying a non-compliance fee for months because no one gave you a portal login, ask for a credit. Processors don’t always grant it, and they’re under no obligation to, but some will refund part of it to keep a merchant from leaving.
Are PCI fees negotiable?
The program fee often is, especially when you’re signing up or threatening to leave. Some processors will waive it, cut it, or fold it into the pricing. It’s worth asking for in writing before you sign, along with every other recurring fee.
The non-compliance fee usually isn’t negotiable as a price, but it’s the easiest fee on your statement to eliminate, because you control whether it applies. A processor that won’t tell you how to stop it, or keeps charging it after you’ve validated, is a processor worth replacing. Our guide on how to switch credit card processors covers how to do that without a gap in your card payments.
As for DFW Pay Pros: we don’t charge monthly fees. The only other charges a merchant might see are software fees, if they need the software, and in some cases an annual fee to cover expenses. Whoever your processor is, an annual fee you can’t get explained is padding, so ask what it covers.
How PCI DSS v4.0.1 fits in
PCI DSS v4.0.1 is the current version of the standard, and it’s the version you’ll validate against when you achieve compliance today. Version 4.0 replaced 3.2.1, and 4.0.1 was a limited revision that clarified wording rather than adding new rules. A set of requirements in v4.0 were labeled “future-dated,” meaning they were best practice at first and became mandatory on March 31, 2025.
For a small merchant on a standalone terminal, the practical effect is mostly in the paperwork. The SAQ forms were updated for the new version, and some questions changed. E-commerce businesses saw more change, particularly around controls on payment pages and scripts that load in a customer’s browser, so if you sell online, read your SAQ closely or ask your web developer or hosting provider for help.
The new compliance requirements didn’t come with a new fee from the council, and processors still set their own PCI prices. If a processor raised your PCI charge and pointed at v4.0 as the reason, ask what changed in the service you’re getting for the extra money.
What happens if you’re not PCI compliant
The monthly fee is the small consequence. The larger risk is what happens if a data breach occurs while you’re non compliant. The card brands can assess your acquiring bank, and the bank can pass those costs to you under your merchant agreement, along with forensic investigation costs and card replacement costs for the issuing banks. A processor can also raise your transaction fees or end your ability to accept credit and debit cards.
Being compliant doesn’t make you immune to a breach, and filing an SAQ doesn’t secure anything by itself. The questionnaire is a checklist of security measures, and it’s only worth something if the answers are true. Using a current terminal, not writing down card numbers, changing default passwords, and keeping your Wi-Fi for customers separate from the network your POS runs on all do more to protect sensitive cardholder data than the paperwork does.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to pay a PCI compliance fee?
If your processor charges one, it’s usually in your merchant agreement, so yes while you’re with that processor. You can ask to have it waived or reduced, and not every processor charges one. PCI compliance itself is mandatory for any business that accepts cards, but the fee is a processor charge, not a card brand or council requirement.
What does a PCI non-compliance fee mean?
It means your processor doesn’t have current proof that you’re PCI compliant. It’s a monthly penalty that keeps billing until you complete your self-assessment questionnaire, pass any required quarterly scans, and your status updates to validated.
Is PCI compliance mandatory?
Yes, for any business that accepts card payments. It’s required by the card brands and written into your merchant agreement, though it isn’t a federal law.
Is PCI compliance required annually?
Yes. Most small merchants revalidate by completing a new SAQ every year, and businesses whose SAQ type requires scans need a passing scan every quarter as well.
How can I get PCI compliant for free?
Filling out the SAQ doesn’t cost anything by itself, and the PCI Security Standards Council publishes the forms. Most processors want it filed through their portal, which your PCI program fee already pays for, so there’s no reason to also pay the non-compliance penalty.
What is a monthly PCI fee?
It’s either a program fee billed monthly instead of yearly, or a non-compliance fee. A small amount that stays the same every month is usually the program fee. A larger amount labeled “non-compliance,” “non-validation” or “non-receipt” is the penalty.
Send us the statement with the PCI line on it
If you’re not sure which PCI charge you’re paying, or why there are two, send us your last three months of statements. We’ll do a free statement review, tell you what each PCI line is, whether it’s the program fee or the penalty, and what your full effective rate comes to with every fee included.
DFW Pay Pros is an independent sales organization, so we place accounts with larger processors and negotiate the pricing on your behalf. There’s no contract, it’s month to month, there’s no early termination fee, and you can cancel any time at no cost. Request a free savings analysis and we’ll show you what you’re paying for and what you can stop paying.